She did not mention his name, but the new Chief of the Army, Susan Coyle, last evening pushed back against the palpable groundswell of support building for Ben Roberts-Smith VC.
Lt-Gen. Coyle challenged a common view among the former Special Air Service corporal’s supporters that his battlefield heroism, the nature of Afghanistan’s insurgency war and passage of time make his prosecution a crime against the venerable history of Australian warriors.
“Some believe there should be no rulebook in war, that the only things that matter are power and violence, that any end is justified if it protects a nation’s soldiers or leads to a form of victory,” she told an event hosted by the Sir Vincent Fairfax Foundation and the Cranlana Centre for Ethical Leadership.
“These views are misguided. Defence values, and the rules that underpin them, must be non-negotiable.”
As Mr Roberts-Smith wages a public relations campaign to bring the nation over to his side — a mission he is convincingly winning on the social media battlefield — a remarkable perspective has emerged.
A PM’s support
Many Australians don’t want Mr Roberts-Smith prosecuted even if he did execute, or order the execution, of the five Afghans listed in the charges against him. This view is not limited to a vocal group of special forces veterans advocating for their hero.
I have met senior lawyers, including judges, who oppose the prosecution, and that of his ex-SAS colleague Oliver Schulz. One former prime minister told Mr Roberts-Smith, according to my sources: “We don’t care what may have happened over there.”
Mr Roberts-Smith told him he appreciated the support but it was counterproductive. He never murdered anyone and always followed the rules of war, he said. Mr Roberts-Smith hasn’t been given the opportunity to plead yet - his trial may be five years away - but has said his greatest fear is being unable to watch his twin teenage daughters grow into women.
Lt-Gen. Coyle’s speech is part of a split within the army between officers and non-officers over the “what happens in war stays in war” attitude held by many of Mr Roberts-Smith’s supporters.
That’s not new. In World War II Australian officers tried to convince the troops to stop executing Japanese prisoners caught in New Guinea. The orders were largely ignored, according to eminent military historian Peter Stanley. No Australians were in the dock at the Tokyo War Crimes Tribunal in 1946.
Selective justice
There are exceptions to the rank-based split.
Retired SAS Brigadier Dan Fortune, who expresses admiration for Lt-Gen. Coyle, has emerged as the leading critic of the Brereton inquiry that concluded there was credible information that 25 special forces soldiers murdered 39 Afghans. On Remembrance Day he complained of an “unequal standard” in the blame attributed to privates, corporals and sergeants compared with the generals who avoided blame, including some of Lt-Gen. Coyle’s predecessors.
Within the SAS, an anti-Roberts-Smith faction of non-officers actively helped the Brereton inquiry and the journalists who first reported the allegations against the Victoria Cross awardee.
Four SAS veterans connected to that group have agreed to testify against Mr Roberts-Smith in return for immunity from murders they admitted to committing in Afghanistan, according to court documents. The ability of these men to avoid culpability for their crimes illustrates the challenge of creating what Lt-Gen. Coyle called in her speech “the moral armour to stand firm against war’s corrupting nature”.
“Many of our soldiers will need to show physical courage in war, but I guarantee they will all need to show moral courage,” she said.
Out of respect to moral courage, the military does not do plea deals. If the four men and Mr Roberts-Smith were being tried by a court-martial, they would not be allowed to escape convictions through informing on each other. Military prosecutors seek to treat all soldiers equally, including those accused of murder.
The invisible $300m
The civilian justice system, where war crimes are now heard, is a jumble of compromises, pragmatism, ideology and public relations.
Federal investigators and prosecutors are under immense pressure to justify a bill of at least $300 million for what has so far resulted in charges against only two veterans, both men approaching their middle ages.
The money comes from the Defence Department. The public service, determined to hide the precise source of the funding, has rejected multiple freedom-of-information requests about the Office of the Special Investigator’s budget. All substantive information from the few emails made public was redacted, leaving comments such as: “Happy Friday. It was nice to chat with you all the other day.”
That secrecy extends to the identity of the four main witnesses. Special forces veterans are not protected from being publicly identified under Defence Force rules. But prosecutors want to shield the four main SAS witnesses from scrutiny — to shore up their psychological resilience — and have sought non-publication orders over their names, a process that looks like the next major stage of Mr Roberts-Smith’s case.
Mr Roberts-Smith’s lawyers oppose the request, figuring if their client is going to be one of the most famous defendants in history then his alleged co-conspirators should put their names to their allegations.
Military sources deny Lt-Gen. Coyle’s speech was not directed at any individual, group or specific incident. But what sounded like an endorsement of war crimes prosecutions will have been welcomed by the government. It must know that the roughly 40,000 people who have bought “Epic 1 Two” t-shirts from Mr Roberts-Smith’s online store are making a political statement as much as a fashion one.
To invert a famous saying, politics is war by another means.
Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.
Sign up for our emails