Legal threat over milk

Brad ThompsonThe West Australian
Legal threat over milk
Camera IconLegal threat over milk Credit: The West Australian

Dairy farmers are considering a legal challenge to long-term supply contracts with Brownes as they prepare for a showdown with the leading milk processor.

Farmers made the threat yesterday after revelations in WestBusiness that Brownes was paying a handful of new suppliers up to 10c a litre more for their milk.

They are weighing up contributing to a fighting fund to see if they can break contracts holding them to lower farm gate prices.

Scott River producer Brad Boley spoke out in support of a legal challenge while other farmers feared commenting publicly under the terms of their contracts.

Get in front of tomorrow's news for FREE

Journalism for the curious Australian across politics, business, culture and opinion.


Mr Boley, who produces about 12 million litres a year and is one of Brownes' biggest suppliers, said he was bitterly disappointed that the company's actions.

"I think that we have to look at a class action," he said.

"People are angry. Everyone expected to get a bit more money this year. It didn't come and the right on back of that we found out about the special deals."

Mr Boley said he was being paid 45c/l compared with 55c/l for farmers on special deals. In the case of his family-run dairy it amounted to a discrepancy of $1.2 million a year.

The third-generation dairy farmer said many others who signed contracts with years to run also faced being left millions of dollars out of pocket.

A host of farmers opted for the certainty of long-term supply contracts about two years ago but since then the WA milk supply has dried up, sparking intense competition among the State's three big processors — Brownes, Harvey Fresh and Lion.

Brownes managing director Ben Purcell, who faces a grilling over the issue at meetings with farmers in the South-West today and tomorrow, said he could not comment on the legal threat.

In a sign of the fierce fighting for milk, Mr Purcell said the loss of a farmer producing 6.5 million litres a year to Parmalat-owned Harvey Fresh forced Brownes to offer a handful of farmers a premium price to shore up supply.

Brownes has just started processing $1-a-litre milk for Woolworths stores under a home-brand contract which runs until 2022. In a separate move, Woolworths will deal direct with WA farmers to launch a new milk brand aimed at the top end of the market after the success of a similar venture in NSW.

"We always said that if it was successful in NSW we would look to replicate it in other places," a Woolworths spokesman said.

"The structure of the dairy market in WA means it is a logical place to do it. We think we can get the farmers and we think we can find a processor happy to process the milk for us."

Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.

Sign up for our emails